I see volvo wants to offload its shares in polestar (48 percent), it will be interesting to see what geely do as they are a major shareholder and comes on the back of a few major manufacturers offloading thier electric divisions. Perhaps reports of the death of combustion engines is a little premature, lets hope
Bash
Polestar
Moderator: Board Moderators
-
OnlineLotus-e-Clan
- Senior Poster
- Posts: 4463
- Joined: Thu Nov 30, 2006 13:25
- Model: Excel SE - EWP/Waterless!
- Colour: Not Blue or Green
- Year: 1989
- Location: Swaledale
Re: Polestar
Good surveillance reporting, bash.bash wrote: ↑Fri Feb 02, 2024 16:58I see volvo wants to offload its shares in polestar (48 percent), it will be interesting to see what geely do as they are a major shareholder and comes on the back of a few major manufacturers offloading thier electric divisions. Perhaps reports of the death of combustion engines is a little premature, lets hope
Bash
Maybe they now see BEVs as the niche market they have become, then?
Maybe also Geely have read the comments (lots of negativity) following Harry's Garage Eletre review (he found a major flaw) and will rethink the 100% BEV strategy for Lotus. Hybrids and full ICE is where it's still at, for a while yet, surely?
Peter K
- MetBlue
- Senior Poster
- Posts: 1445
- Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2018 21:00
- Model: Elite 74 & Excel 92 (SEish))
- Colour: Metalic Blue
- Year: 1974
- Location: Northampton
Re: Polestar
This articles coming on a year old now, but maybe there's hope for the ICE yet.
Tony
What goes together.... Must come apart.
-
- Junior Poster
- Posts: 61
- Joined: Sun May 29, 2022 21:47
- Model: Excel
- Colour: Blue
- Year: 1986
- Location: Fort Worth, TX
Re: Polestar
With Jaguar going all-electric and up-market, plus 85% of their US dealerships bailing out on them, including my two closest, I'm thinking its time to get a new daily driver myself. Last year I had to stop for service at a Jaguar dealer 900 miles from home and that dealership is gone now too. I want something that I could drive on a 1,500 mile trip without having to make detailed plans and schedules around every charging stop. But I also want something that can be repaired quickly by almost anyone anywhere. I don't want a niche-market car that can only be repaired by a few specialized technicians or might be in the shop for weeks or months while they struggle with diagnosis and wait on parts.
I work in public transit and we're starting to experiment with electric buses. We have six that we've been running about four years now. Don't let anyone fool you that electric vehicles are more reliable because there are fewer moving parts to break. That may be true to an irrelevant extent, but these large battery packs and controllers are still new technology and what we are experiencing is that they are failing in ways that the engineers never imagined. When one breaks, our technicians aren't familiar enough with them beyond the rudimentary training they received. So we spend days online with the manufacturers tech support trying to diagnose the problem or sometimes they even give up and fly somebody out. Then when the problem is discovered, the part is not just sitting on a shelf somewhere ready to go. The manufacturer has to place an order with their supplier to "make" the needed part. Then they slot it in with a future production batch and we wait. When an ICE bus breaks down (and we run compressed natural gas, which is cleaner than diesel), we can have a whole new engine in it overnight. When an electric bus breaks down, its down for a whole month......minimum.... a MONTH! The charging facilities are another issue. So far, we've rarely had all three chargers working at the same time.
I applaud the early adopters. Somebody has to go first, experience the pain and aggravation in the name of progress. At the turn of the last century, gasoline/petrol wasn't readily available at every street corner and highway interchange, there weren't dealerships in every medium to large city plus ICE was not yet very reliable technology. I remember my grandfather's story of his father's marathon trip halfway across the US in 1925 to retrieve the body of his brother who'd died in an accident in San Francisco. The trip had to be made very, very quickly as one might imagine, and under very primitive circumstances. He purchased a brand new Chevrolet truck and took off after only a driving lesson from the salesman, having never even driven a motor vehicle before. To him is was really new technology, but it appeared to be the right tool for the job and it was. Who knows, if electricity had been more widespread back then, the battery electric car might have become the norm. But in 2024, EV tech has a long way to go to catch up to the convenience and reliability provided by 140+ years of ICE vehicle development.
I don't know if the technology isn't ready for me or I'm not ready for it, probably both. They might have gotten me to dip a toe in with a plug-in hybrid, but nobody makes a PHEV model that would appeal to me. Actually nobody makes anything that I really want right now, but that'd be getting way off topic.
I work in public transit and we're starting to experiment with electric buses. We have six that we've been running about four years now. Don't let anyone fool you that electric vehicles are more reliable because there are fewer moving parts to break. That may be true to an irrelevant extent, but these large battery packs and controllers are still new technology and what we are experiencing is that they are failing in ways that the engineers never imagined. When one breaks, our technicians aren't familiar enough with them beyond the rudimentary training they received. So we spend days online with the manufacturers tech support trying to diagnose the problem or sometimes they even give up and fly somebody out. Then when the problem is discovered, the part is not just sitting on a shelf somewhere ready to go. The manufacturer has to place an order with their supplier to "make" the needed part. Then they slot it in with a future production batch and we wait. When an ICE bus breaks down (and we run compressed natural gas, which is cleaner than diesel), we can have a whole new engine in it overnight. When an electric bus breaks down, its down for a whole month......minimum.... a MONTH! The charging facilities are another issue. So far, we've rarely had all three chargers working at the same time.
I applaud the early adopters. Somebody has to go first, experience the pain and aggravation in the name of progress. At the turn of the last century, gasoline/petrol wasn't readily available at every street corner and highway interchange, there weren't dealerships in every medium to large city plus ICE was not yet very reliable technology. I remember my grandfather's story of his father's marathon trip halfway across the US in 1925 to retrieve the body of his brother who'd died in an accident in San Francisco. The trip had to be made very, very quickly as one might imagine, and under very primitive circumstances. He purchased a brand new Chevrolet truck and took off after only a driving lesson from the salesman, having never even driven a motor vehicle before. To him is was really new technology, but it appeared to be the right tool for the job and it was. Who knows, if electricity had been more widespread back then, the battery electric car might have become the norm. But in 2024, EV tech has a long way to go to catch up to the convenience and reliability provided by 140+ years of ICE vehicle development.
I don't know if the technology isn't ready for me or I'm not ready for it, probably both. They might have gotten me to dip a toe in with a plug-in hybrid, but nobody makes a PHEV model that would appeal to me. Actually nobody makes anything that I really want right now, but that'd be getting way off topic.
Phil - 86 Excel SE
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2227
- Joined: Wed Feb 06, 2013 15:06
- Model: Elite S2.2 Automatic
- Colour: Essex Blue
- Year: 1981
- Location: Worcestershire
Re: Polestar
The difference is that petrol power developed under the forces of a free market - more convenient, cost effective etc. Electric vehicles only exist because of government diktat and subsidy. What could possibly go wrong?
Richard
Richard
- rbgosling
- Senior Poster
- Posts: 1723
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 22:55
- Model: Lotus Excel SE
- Colour: Midnight Blue
- Year: 1990
- Location: Rugby
Re: Polestar
If Ford could make more profit building a car that throws a little bit of arsenic out of it's tailpipe, and it would save me a bit of money to buy it, then the free market would dictate that Ford would build it and I would buy it. After all, the 0.00001% of British arsenic tailpipe emissions I was personally responsible for is not going to hurt me, or anyone else. But when 10,000,000 people buy the Ford Arsenic, soon everyone in the country will be dead. When the required change benefits the whole of the country, rather than individuals, only the government can make it happen, either by banning something outright, or deliberately manipulating the market so the beneficial choice is also the most economic choice.
Now, whether the BEV is the right solution to causing less pollution is an entirely different argument! And how the government should go about making things happen, and whether it's any good at it, can be very contentious. I'm just saying, in principle, the free market doesn't have all the answers.
Sorry, I'm dragging this very much into the "Off Topic" direction!
"Farmer" Richard
1990 Lotus Excel SE (Lilith)
2022 MG MG5 EV (not due to be a classic for quite a few years...)
2011 Nissan Leaf (Ragly - EV pioneer, must be due to be a classic one day)
1990 Lotus Excel SE (Lilith)
2022 MG MG5 EV (not due to be a classic for quite a few years...)
2011 Nissan Leaf (Ragly - EV pioneer, must be due to be a classic one day)
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2227
- Joined: Wed Feb 06, 2013 15:06
- Model: Elite S2.2 Automatic
- Colour: Essex Blue
- Year: 1981
- Location: Worcestershire
Re: Polestar
There is a big difference between a well regulated free market that controls harmful by-products of human activity and a totalitarian future in which we will be told what we can do, which is where we seem to be heading. The free market is the best mechanism we have for identifying solutions; state planning manifestly is not. On a linked subject, I’m encouraged by the success of the farmers’ protests across Europe.rbgosling wrote: ↑Tue Feb 06, 2024 16:30If Ford could make more profit building a car that throws a little bit of arsenic out of it's tailpipe, and it would save me a bit of money to buy it, then the free market would dictate that Ford would build it and I would buy it. After all, the 0.00001% of British arsenic tailpipe emissions I was personally responsible for is not going to hurt me, or anyone else. But when 10,000,000 people buy the Ford Arsenic, soon everyone in the country will be dead. When the required change benefits the whole of the country, rather than individuals, only the government can make it happen, either by banning something outright, or deliberately manipulating the market so the beneficial choice is also the most economic choice.
Now, whether the BEV is the right solution to causing less pollution is an entirely different argument! And how the government should go about making things happen, and whether it's any good at it, can be very contentious. I'm just saying, in principle, the free market doesn't have all the answers.
Sorry, I'm dragging this very much into the "Off Topic" direction!
Also see my post in Off Topic: viewtopic.php?f=12&t=13051
Richard
- rbgosling
- Senior Poster
- Posts: 1723
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 22:55
- Model: Lotus Excel SE
- Colour: Midnight Blue
- Year: 1990
- Location: Rugby
Re: Polestar
Where the line is between "well regulated market" and "totalitarian regime" is something that there will always be widely varying views on!
"Farmer" Richard
1990 Lotus Excel SE (Lilith)
2022 MG MG5 EV (not due to be a classic for quite a few years...)
2011 Nissan Leaf (Ragly - EV pioneer, must be due to be a classic one day)
1990 Lotus Excel SE (Lilith)
2022 MG MG5 EV (not due to be a classic for quite a few years...)
2011 Nissan Leaf (Ragly - EV pioneer, must be due to be a classic one day)